A Surprising Look at Murderhobos...

So I asked a question on Facebook this week. What did people do with the humanoid women and children in the Caves of Chaos, among similar adventures, persumably? This was a controversial question, given that killing non-combatants is genocide and a war crime in the civilized world, and that (hopefully) players have a functioning moral compass precluding even simulated atrocities, at least not without certain disclaimers...

The answers ran the gamut, although some were obviously tongue-in-cheek: 

40% chose to treat such non-combatants humanely in various ways.

30% modified the encounter(s) to remove the very presence of said innocents.

20% chose slaughter, some citing variations of the Nuremberg Defense.

10% enslaved these helpless survivors, marching them to the Keep in chains. 

This data is current as of this morning, and I filtered out the nonsense replies and Full Metal Jacket references (humerous as they might otherwise be) to get the meat...

And the meat, consistent with my own experience (starting in 1978), is that most players choose a humane response, likely in deference to their personal morality, opting for Lawful or Good characters for similar reasons. Those who chose attrocities were generally younger, meaning less mature, or older and able to skillfully roleplay. Regardless, it's a compelling look into old-schoolers, proving that people are still people, age or edition be damned.